Skip to content

Paul Miller: A Year Without Internet

Paul Miller is a technology writer living in New York City and on May 1st, 2012 he decided to leave the Internet for year.

“I thought the Internet might be an unnatural state for us humans, or at least for me. Maybe I was too ADD to handle it, or too impulsive to restrain my usage. I'd used the Internet constantly since I was twelve, and as my livelihood since I was fourteen. I'd gone from paperboy, to web designer, to technology writer in under a decade. I didn't know myself apart from a sense of ubiquitous connection and endless information. I wondered what else there was to life. "Real life," perhaps, was waiting for me on the other side of the web browser.” (Miller)

Miller writes for an online technology publication called The Verge, which he planned on quitting while on his Internet hiatus. Unexpectedly, however, the company was interested in following him through his year without the Internet, and continued to pay him to write articles which he submitted hard copy.

For the first few months, Miller saw his experiment as a huge success, “My life was full of serendipitous events: real life meetings, Frisbee, bike rides, and Greek literature. With no clear idea how I did it, I wrote half my novel, and turned in an essay nearly every week to The Verge.” (Miller) He writes further about a lengthened attention span and more sincere connections with those around him and with the world in general. He claims that there was little he missed from the Internet; that he simply traded in GPS for maps, texts for phone calls, and email for a box at the post office.

About half a year in, however, the honeymoon phase wore off and he found his Frisbee gathering dust in the corner, a relic of his efforts to break old habits. “Most weeks I don't go out with people even once. My favorite place is the couch. I prop my feet up on the coffee table, play a video game, and listen to an audiobook.” (Miller) He has fallen back into similar routines as in his Internet days, only with new distractions from the “real world”.

After coming back he doesn’t really know if the experiment was worth it. He reflects in his mini-documentary posted below, that he started the project to understand how the Internet affected his productivity, creativity and to figure out how the Internet impacts him. “The last time I knew myself without the Internet was when I was about twelve. I hope that I can capture a little bit of that stupid imagination that kid had. Before I had the internet I used my computer to write an allegorical fiction where me and my siblings rooms were different kingdoms and I was also making stop-animation short films. After I got the Internet I used AIM and did message boards.” (Miller)

Almost a year into the project he felt overwhelmed because of his isolation from the human race. He realized that there are deeper problems affecting his ability to connect with people that simply manifest themselves differently on and off line. “It (the experiment) didn’t really work. There’s been some awesome things from this year, but as far as my thesis setting out, I’ve got a year to do all this awesome stuff and I didn’t do half of it. I ended up playing a lot of video games… and I still feel overwhelmed its just a different kind of overwhelmed; its more existential and has less concrete factors.” (Miller) The Internet created a permeable wall for Miller behind which he felt safe and could build relationships online from the comfort of his couch; it served him as a way he could interact in, for him, a less difficult way. It was simply the amount of interaction that overwhelmed him. But when the wall of the Internet was gone the reality of those relationships set in.

Two things that Miller wrote really struck me:

“So much ink has been spilled deriding the false concept of a "Facebook friend," but I can tell you that a "Facebook friend" is better than nothing.” (Miller)

And,

“There’s a lot of “reality” in our virtual, and a lot of “virtual” in our reality.” (Miller)

The important point that both of these quotes address is, unless people are comfortable feeling slightly disconnected from those around them, they must be connected online, as it is now such an essential part of relationships and communication in our culture. While some people may be able to handle the isolation that comes from going without the Internet, Paul Miller struggled with it. It forced him to address some deeper issues that were present and simply being covered up by the distraction of the Internet. He didn’t seem to think this was a good thing; that he isolated himself too much. After reading his pieces and watching his mini-documentary however, I disagree. Though he may have felt even more isolated without the Internet than with, going without it showed him that the Internet was not the immediate cause of this problem.

In my interpretation, Paul is a prime example of the long-term affects of Internet use. He mentioned his rampant creativity when he was younger, could it be that the Internet dumbed him down? That with its instant gratification, and virtual connectivity, that it prevented him from further developing his creativity and social skill, thus preventing him from building those connections without it? Maybe the Internet is the cause of you feeling overwhelmed Paul, just not in the way you thought.

 

 Mini-Documentary - Finding Paul Miller

Interesting Sources

Paul Miller's larger articles on the experiment:

http://www.theverge.com/2013/5/1/4279674/im-still-here-back-online-after-a-year-without-the-internet

http://www.theverge.com/2012/4/30/2988798/paul-miller-year-without-internet

Criticism: 

http://readwrite.com/2013/05/03/quitting-the-internet-is-a-dumb-idea#awesm=~ozwV5LPzNpEO03

 

Back to main screen
 DISCUSSION
#1 POSTED BY Dominique Brielle Fluker, 04/02 8:18 PM

Really interesting perspective of leaving the internet and having feelings of withdrawal and isolation, as well as freedom. I think it is important to assess how much the internet has been a vital role within our society and has shaped us indefinitely. I appreciated this post!

#2 POSTED BY guest guest, 04/02 8:26 PM

I think this illustrates a really great point -- for introverted or socially awkward people like Paul Miller (or me, honestly), the Internet provides a great way to maintain social contact in a comfortable way. Rather than making people who would otherwise be out happily interacting face-to-face stay inside, it gives people who would stay inside more often no matter what a means of avoiding total isolation. 

#3 POSTED BY Matthew Graham Silver, 04/03 12:04 AM

I think this post makes a serious case for the notion of the Internet becoming a necessity in the modern world. Have their been reactions by any noteworthy professionals regarding this situation? I would argue that if not having the Internet creates such as disparity in the quality of life for someone who choses not to use it, that has serious real world ramifications that need to be addressed. Should the Internet become a free resource to combat this isolation/difficulty? What are your thoughts on this?

#4 POSTED BY guest guest, 02/18 10:39 AM

#5 POSTED BY guest guest, 04/03 10:08 AM

https://themepalace.com/users/richards23/ https://www.synapticon.com/users/8ddf57a797497f19 https://ivorysearch.com/users/richards23 https://metrocount.com/users/richards24/ https://www.routesnorth.com/users/richards24/ https://millcomputing.com/users/richards24 https://www.uradmonitor.com/users/richards24 https://support.rankmath.com/users/appstalkers32/ https://www.giuspen.com/users/richards24/ https://www.supersprings.com/users/appstalkers32/ https://thibarmy.com/users/appstalkers32/ https://rakarnov.com/users/richards24 http://www.playfaeria.com/users/richards24 https://crowsnestsoftware.com/users/richards24/ https://www.campsitephotos.com/forums/users/richards24/ https://blokforge.com/users/appstalkers32/ https://1sheeld.com/users/richards24/ https://bloomfromthedarkness.com/users/richards24 https://www.reallyhelpfulclub.com/users/richards24/ https://www.totallyuniqueideas.com/users/richards24/ https://forum.heyitsaura.com/users/richards24 https://codevibrant.com/users/richards24/ https://momsmeet.com/users/appstalkers32gmail-com/ https://thebarreblog.com/users/richards24 http://tmsyou.com/users/richards24 http://www.mocomakers.com/users/richards24 https://www.coothemes.com/users/richards24 https://www.icecoldapps.com/users/richards24 https://www.electronicsforgeeks.com/users/richards24 https://www.synthetos.com/users/richards24 http://www.kiwijs.org/users/richards24 https://akacatholic.com/users/richards24/ https://www.ntminfo.org/users/richards24/ https://plantspace.org/users/richards24/ https://gingerhealthcare.org/users/richards24/ http://www.middlewaysociety.org/users/richards24/ https://jordanthomasfoundation.org/users/richards24 https://accounts.eclipse.org/users/rsmithmdg http://www.pokerleague.org/users/richards24/ https://www.dfxllc.net/users/richards24/ https://tabbles.net/users/app-stalkers/ https://finalcutprox.net/users/app_stalkers/ http://www.metalstorm.net/users/richards24/profile https://rpgmaker.net/users/richards24/ https://members.luscious.net/users/1555983/ https://check-caller.net/users/richards24 http://mauer.co/users/richards24 https://steemit.com/@richards24 https://gebb.io/users/richards24 https://kitsu.io/users/472681 https://www.meetfighters.com/users/richards24

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

#6 POSTED BY guest guest, 04/21 3:52 PM

situs poker online judi poker uang asli Situs Poker Cepat Situs Poker Idn Situs Poker Indonesia Situs Poker Jackpot Terbesar Situs Poker Judi Online Situs Poker Online Asia dewa poker dewapoker game online poker game poker game poker indonesia game poker online game poker online indonesia game poker online pc login qq mobile poker online mobile poker88 permainan online terbaik permainan poker games poker online gaplepoker idn indonesia idn play indoplay capsa susun indopoker judipoker judipoker link judipoker online permainan poker online game poker online permainan poker uang asli remi poker online agen judi poker online poker online terpercaya poker indo asli poker online uang asli judi kartu online terpercaya judi kiu kiu judi kiu kiu online judi on line judi onlin judi onlin terpercaya judi online judi online 88 judi online android kartu poker kartu poker online kiu kiu online android kiu kiu online terpercaya kiu kiu poker kiu online liga poker link alternatif poker link alternatif poker online link judi online link judi poker judi ceme judi ceme online judi ceme online terpercaya judi ceme terpercaya ceme poker ceme jackpot ceme judi online ceme online ceme online terbaik ceme online terpercaya ceme domino domino online judi domino online terpercaya domino ceme online domino harga domino judi domino judi online domino kiu domino kiu kiu online domino online capsa judi online capsa online capsa online uang asli capsa susun indoplay capsa susun judi Judi Poker Judi Poker 88 Judi Poker Android Judi Poker Indonesia Judi Poker Online Dengan Uang Asli Judi Poker Online Tanpa Deposit Judi Poker Online Tanpa Modal Judi Poker Online Terpercaya Judi Poker Online Uang Asli Judi Poker QQ Judi Poker Terbaik Judi Poker Terpercaya Ceme Ceme 99 Ceme Ceme Ceme Domino Ceme Jackpot Ceme Judi Online Ceme Online Terbaik Ceme Online Terpercaya Ceme Poker Ceme QQ Ceme99 

#7 POSTED BY guest guest, 04/21 3:53 PM

qq online qqpokerasia pokerbola pokerqiu qqpoker asiapoker pokerqq pokerbola2 asia poker qq poker poker asia pokerindo agen poker online qqdomino poker indonesia poker bola pokerasia poker online indonesia qq poker online game poker online judi online terpercaya permainan domino as poker game qq permainan poker main poker qq domino poker online uang asli terbaru dompetpoker bandar judi qq poker online terpercaya 2019 situs poker terbaru dan terpercaya 2019 cara main domino qqpokeronline live chat idnplay poker daftar domino qq online situs poker online resmi situs poker terpercaya poker online terbaik situs judi bola terpercaya poker online uang asli situs poker online paling bagus poker online indonesia terbaik game gaple online poker susun poker poker judi online poker poker online uang asli terbaik main poker tanpa modal dapat uang qiu qiu online indonesia gaple online uang asli domino qiu qiu terbaru ceme online terbaik poker uang asli terpercaya game poker online terbaik daftar poker online terbaru poker indonesia terbaik pokerdex capsa online indo qiuqiu judi qiuqiu domino qiu qiu capsa susun online poker online agen poker online poker online terpercaya poker online uang asli qq online terpercaya daftar situs poker online terbaik judi poker terpercaya game poker terbaik bandar ceme terpercaya bandar poker terpercaya judi poker terbaik poker online uang asli terpercaya situs judi poker terbaik capsa susun capsa capsa online bandarq situs poker online resmi qiuqiu poker online terpercaya tangkasnet bola tangkas judi online situs qq terbaik poker terpercaya poker terbaik situs qq terpercaya agen qq terpercaya poker indonesia terpercaya dominoqq terpercaya situs domino terpercaya domino uang asli terpercaya highlucky ion casino highlucky ion casino joker213 daftar joker123 judi online terpercaya situs judi qq online terpercaya bandar online terpercaya agen judi online terpercaya judi ceme terpercaya agen poker online terpercaya judi qq terpercaya poker indonesia terbaik judi poker online terpercaya p2play poker online agen poker online poker online terpercaya poker online uang asli judi qiuqiu domino qiu qiu capsa susun online capsa online daftar poker online Tri7 Tri7bet situs qq online terpercaya situs judi terpercaya poker online uang asli terbaik situs judi capsa online terpercaya bandar poker online terpercaya judi qq online terpercaya bandar judi online terpercaya domino online terpercaya bandar qq terpercaya situs judi online judi bola online situs online judi terbaik situs poker online terpercaya ceme online terbaik judi kartu online terpercaya agen poker online indonesia terpercaya bandar judi terpercaya judi ceme online terpercaya daftar judi online terpercaya agen qq online terpercaya 

#8 POSTED BY guest guest, 06/21 2:22 AM

Good article and have a nice content, really enjoy it. thanks for sharing.
Visit our site on :

[url=https://www.liga588.net]Judi Bola Online[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Jasa Bola[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Liga 88[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Judi Slot[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Liga88[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Agen Judi Bola SBOBET[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Casino Online[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Bola88[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Lapak Judi Bola[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Judi Live Casino Terpercaya[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Bola 88[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]JasaBola[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]IDN Poker Terpercaya[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Poker Online[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Dewa Poker[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Dewa Poker 88[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Poker88[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Tangkas88[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Judi Slot Online[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Tembak Ikan[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Judi Poker[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Slot Online[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Judi Online[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Agen Bola[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Bola Online[/url]
[url=https://www.liga588.net]Situs Slot[/url]

#9 POSTED BY guest guest, 06/21 2:27 AM

POST A COMMENT

MySLC Help